‘Pirates’: No cannonballs fly this time — but is the story seaworthy?

May 18, 2011 | 3:16 p.m.
pirates johnny depp penelope cruz johnny depp ian mcshane Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy?

Penelope Cruz, Johnny Depp and Ian McShane in "Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides" (Walt Disney Co.)

There’s a moment in the new “Pirates of the Caribbean” film when a peg-legged privateer calls his crew to battle stations — an enemy ship has been spotted on the horizon — and the Disney franchise appears poised for another one of its signature sea battles. But the high-seas skirmish never happens and, in a bit of shocker, not one cannonball flies in all 137 minutes of this buccaneer blockbuster.

piratespremiere Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy?

See the "Pirates" stars at Cannes

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides” arrives in theaters Friday with an expensive star in Johnny Depp and a production budget somewhere north of $200 million just to make the film. Still, the project was a tighter ship when it came to visual effects and those open-ocean scenes that drive up costs on a movie. From a creative standpoint, the filmmakers say they were looking to refresh the franchise with new faces and a new, leaner plot line.

“The idea was absolutely to distill what is best about the franchise and concentrate on that,” said director Rob Marshall. “The effects should work in service of the story too, not the other way around.”

Months ago, producer Jerry Bruckheimer said screenwriters Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio were specifically instructed to craft a story with a shore-leave mentality that would limit the high cost of shooting on the high seas. The result is a movie with jungle chase scenes, a visit to London and plenty of sword fights but none of the ship-to-ship combat that stretches the screen and the budget. Also, with an eye on the bottom line, there are no central characters that require major computer-generated effects the way the octopus-faced Davy Jones did in the two previous films.

 Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy?

Penelope Cruz and Rob Marshall, director of "Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides," walk arm-in-arm after the film's Cannes premiere. (Vittorio Zunino Celotto / Getty Images)

Bruckheimer blanches at the suggestion that the new film — the fourth in the series — is anything less than epic. The franchise has racked up $2.6 billion in worldwide box office, but the producer said this adventure needed to go to new places. Bruckheimer and Disney also remember that reviewers attacked the last movie for putting digital spectacle ahead of a coherent story.

“Story, pure story,” Bruckheimer said of the choice to pare down the special effects (there are 1,100 visual-effects shots in “On Stranger Tides,” down from about 2,000 in the previous outing). “We give the script to our visual-effects people and they say, ‘Here’s the count.’ Sometimes, if you have budget problems, you’ll cut a sequence out, but we were very fortunate. We came in very close to where they wanted us to. The movie was on budget, which is unusual but good.”

None of this is to say that money wasn’t spent on the project, far from it. It seems as if every bus and billboard in America has Depp’s face on it, and after four international premieres — in London and Moscow and at Disneyland and the Cannes Film Festival in France — marketing and advertising costs will push the total project price tag to $400 million or more.

blackbeard Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy?

Ian McShane as Blackbeard in "Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides" (Peter Mountain / Walt Disney Co.)

The investment appears to be paying off; prerelease surveys show robust audience interest and industry observers are expecting a massive opening-weekend box office. This is the first “Pirates” film to benefit from the pricier 3-D tickets; the movie will also be shown on 402 Imax screens, a record number.

Marshall said the emphasis this time was on a well-told tale, humor and a brisk pace. The plot presents Depp’s Capt. Jack Sparrow in search of the Fountain of Youth, which is also being sought by old rival Hector Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) and franchise newcomers Blackbeard (Ian McShane) and Angelica (Penelope Cruz), along with Spanish King Ferdinand (Sebastian Armesto).

The movie is 33 minutes shorter than the previous installment, but Marshall doubts that anyone will feel cheated.

johnnydepp1 Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy?

Johnny Depp in "Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides." (Walt Disney Co.)

“It’s one of the things I loved about the script, it is new and a chance to reinvent the action we present,” said Marshall, who took over for Gore Verbinski, captain of the first three movies. “This is different. We don’t have ship-to-ship battles. Instead we have a centerpiece scene with mermaids, these sirens of the sea, and it’s such a great, new original idea.”

Those mermaids sang their seductive song mostly at Falls Lake, a vast 2.7 million-gallon tank on the Universal Studios lot — a far cry from the first film, for which construction crews built three piers and a back lot on the Caribbean isle of St. Vincent. “On Stranger Tides” was filmed in Hawaiian jungles and beaches and in London, where tax credits are more favorable. The number of shooting days was kept around 106, down from 142. For Blackbeard’s ship, the production team stripped down the Black Pearl, Sparrow’s ship from the previous films, and redressed it in a Hollywood version of recycling.

However, don’t try to suggest to Bruckheimer that those fiscal decisions somehow add up to a creative discount.

“Forget the tax credit,” he said. “We wanted to start the new series in a whole different place, not the Caribbean, to give the audience something fresh and new. The tax break was an added advantage, but it was always a creative decision, and it was made early on.”

Even the star of the film said sometimes less is more. Depp said, for instance, that even his head began to swim while shooting a loopy scene in the last movie, in which Captain Jack finds himself in Davy Jones’ locker and is confronted by multiple versions of himself, a goat and an elusive peanut.

“It was probably the most expensive surreal sequence in the history of movies,” he said. “There were times along the way where I turned to Gore, [and said] ‘OK, what’s going on again?’ There was so much imagination and we had to keep topping what came before,” Depp recalled. “This time it was very important to us that we made a movie that had room to breathe and an openness for the audience.”

— Geoff Boucher, Dawn C. Chmielewski and Rebecca Keegan


pirates of the caribbean stranger tides2 Pirates: No cannonballs fly this time    but is the story seaworthy? El Capitan hosts ‘Pirates’ marathon

‘Pirates 4′  director on the joys of Johnny

McShane: Depp gets ‘national debt’-size payday

Depp: ‘Pirates’ will sail until ‘the people get tired of it’

Keith Richards: Still shocked by Disney gig

‘Pirates’ team: This time our movie will make sense

‘Pirates’ king Jerry Bruckheimer gets royal treatment

24 FRAMES: Keira Knightley’s new adventure

Author finds himself aboard ‘Pirates’ ship

‘Ranger’: Johnny Depp won’t be traditional Tonto


10 Responses to ‘Pirates’: No cannonballs fly this time — but is the story seaworthy?

  1. donutman says:

    Really upset that there won't be any ship battles…

  2. duanesm says:

    You won't miss them. Saw the film last night and loved it. I'd rather have a better story than end up with the bloated battles of the last film. "On Stranger Tides" was much more like the original film, which I enjoyed immensely more than the second, and even more than the third. :)

  3. JOJO says:

    I can't wait to see it!!

  4. Clancy says:

    No one ever mentions that it's from a novel by a great writer named Tim Powers.

  5. Jobb says:

    I loved the first film and didn't love the second or third. Would be glad for a chance to get back to the story and humor of the first.

  6. Donut says:

    I like the ride at Disneyland. There are ship battles on that, and the kind of women that would get pregnant by the Cal. Governor. Whether they wanted to or not.

  7. Tracy says:

    I love the series but Pirates of the Caribbean without Elizabeth Swann? No, thank you.

  8. studiowestvideo says:

    No ship battles or too much FX. So what 'exactly' cost over 200 million? My money says this was a money grab by the producers and Depp.

  9. cpjalufka says:

    The first two films are incredibly fun. The third labored on and on, going nowhere. I am looking forward to this new installment. Fresh characters and a new director doesn't always make a good film, but this time I think it could.

    I'm glad they cut Orlando Bloom's and Kiera Knightly's characters. There stories were done in the second one.

  10. alex says:

    Oh i better go watch this because May21st it won't matter and Disney will be smighth

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

E-mail It
Powered by ShareThis