‘Sucker Punch’: Zack Snyder says films with heroines still ‘a challenge economically’

Jan. 09, 2011 | 9:10 a.m.

Hero Complex writer Rebecca Keegan looks at the new challenges and opportunities for teen heroines in cinema in a comprehensive piece just published in the Los Angeles Times, “Teen girls in film showcase true grit.” Here’s an excerpt that will be of particular interest to Hero Complex readers.

sucker punch vaness hudgens Sucker Punch: Zack Snyder says films with heroines still a challenge economically

Vanessa Hudgens in "Sucker Punch," promotional poster. (Warner Bros.)

Traditionally, one of the barriers to teen female protagonists driving anything but romances has been the conventional wisdom in Hollywood that such characters alienate male audiences. That didn’t seem to be a problem for the Coens’ True Grit,” however. Though the PG-13 film is built squarely around Hailee Steinfeld’s performance, its marketing emphasized its male stars, and “True Grit” has brought in more than $86 million at the box office so far on the shoulders of mostly male moviegoers.

hunger games Sucker Punch: Zack Snyder says films with heroines still a challenge economically Ideally for filmmakers, these heroines don’t turn off men and entice women and girls to genres they might ordinarily skip. At least that’s what Zack Snyder would like to accomplish with the upcoming movie “Sucker Punch,” a feminine twist on the prison-break film in which an 18-year-old character named Baby Doll (played by 22-year-old Emily Browning) fights her way out of a mental institution using her mind, her fellow patients and some samurai swords.

“We have female characters in this situation that’s mostly the terrain of men,” says Snyder, whose film is due in theaters in March. “It’s a challenge economically to find who is the audience for the movie. Our hope is that the movie is transcendent, that it becomes something no one’s seen before and exists outside the models [studios] use to track potential economic gains.”

Young women have wielded authority in genre movies in the past — Princess Leia, after all, was mighty handy with a blaster. “Buffy the Vampire Slayer,” an early ’90s film, inspired a much more influential 1997-2003 TV series in which Sarah Michelle Gellar battled the torments of both the undead and high school. At first marketed to teen girls, it became a crossover hit with boys.

“Getting beat up by Buffy was not a problem for guys,” notes Patricia White, professor of film and media studies at Swarthmore College. Warner Bros. will revisit the iconic character in a Buffy film slated for release in 2012.

More of these “Rambolinas” are on the way to cineplexes: In April, in the titular role of “Hanna,” a 14-year-old assassin-in-training played by Saoirse Ronan journeys across Europe on her first, dangerous mission. In “The Hunger Games,” a potential franchise about to begin casting, Katniss Everdeen, the 16-year-old huntress from the bestselling series of dystopian novels, volunteers to fight to the death in a government-staged arena game to save her younger sister’s life. And [“Winter’s Bone” director Debra] Granik and her producing partner, Anne Rosellini, are working on a film treatment for one of fiction’s original tomboys, Pippi Longstocking.


— Rebecca Keegan


whit anderson Sucker Punch: Zack Snyder says films with heroines still a challenge economically

Joss who? Meet the “Buffy” fan writing the new movie

Joss Whedon responds with wit and worry

“Hunger Games” star search: “No front-runner yet”

“Hunger Games”: How Gary Ross got the directing job

“Sucker Punch” amps up the grrrrl power

“Sucker Punch” — a special brand of girl crazy

Believe it or not: Ripley of “Alien” is greatest sci-fi female

It’s on: “Twilight” vs. “Buffy”

“Wonderland” star searches for girl “beneath iconic figure”

Stephenie Meyer and the future of “Midnight Sun”


5 Responses to ‘Sucker Punch’: Zack Snyder says films with heroines still ‘a challenge economically’

  1. regina says:

    This article is a pile of stupid and I feel dumber for having read it. If Sucker Punch starred males, it wouldn't be set in a brothel and they wouldn't be strippers threatened with rape.

  2. Samantha says:

    I think Sucker Punch is an awesome new concept and shows true grit so what its in the brothel? They are breaking out of the mold of the leading ladies mind of being victims and escaping. Alot of mental institutions have numerous unreported rapes so it's a real life situation to yes it is wrong but it happens. They are showing that even if you are in a position where you feel impotent you can break free. I also like the fighting sequence of Vanessa Hudgens this will be a break out role for her to get her out of the scope of High School Musical. A great cast of varied actors to John Hamm is wonderful.

  3. deepwater805 says:

    Note to Hollywood: It’s not having teenage girls as strong hero types that turn off us hairy legged guy types. It’s bad scripts that turn us off.

    • Laer Carroll says:

      Absolutely right. It was the terrible script for Catwoman that did it in. Not Halle Berry, who is not only super sexy but a terrific actress. (She did not get an Oscar for being gorgeous.) She was perfect for the part.

  4. Laer Carroll says:

    "female protagonists driving anything but romances" DO NOT "alienate male audiences." It's terrible scripts which alienate us. We love kick-ass fem heroes, whether they fight physically or with smarts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

E-mail It
Powered by ShareThis