‘Shutter Island’ is a different nightmare in graphic novel form

Jan. 01, 2010 | 6:13 p.m.

GRAPHIC NOVEL REVIEW

Shutter Island graphic novel

SHUTTER ISLAND

Story by Dennis Lehane and art by Christian De Metter

Tokyopop/HarperCollins, $21.99

On sale in the U.S. on Jan. 5

Back in 1941, a Russian immigrant named Albert Lewis Kanter had (literally) a novel idea for the fledgling medium of the American comic book — he launched Classics Illustrated, a series that lived up to its name by converting “Ivanhoe,” “Jane Eyre,” “The Iliad” and scores of other bookshelf familiars into funny-book fodder. It was a high-minded mission, really, but it had its share of creaky moments; let’s face it, a 52-page comic book isn’t the most obvious format for “Lord Jim.”

The yearning to transfer established literature to the comic-book spinner rack continues. I’d love to see the expression on Kanter’s face if he had lived long enough to see a copy of the new graphic novel “Shutter Island,”  which adapts the 2003 prose novel of the same name by Dennis Lehane. Profane, terrifying, trippy and unrelentingly grim, this adaptation by gifted French artist Christian De Metter would have scared the bejesus out of Kanter and just about anyone else from a generation that expected comic books to be more like Woody Woodpecker than “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.”

The graphic novel is religiously (and gruesomely) faithful to Lehane’s novel and with good reason — it would be hard to tamper with the circuitry of such a meticulously crafted mystery. The visual demands and page-count realities of the new medium required some tough choices, but De Metter has handled them deftly. The plot of the original novel was purposely confounding in certain dark corners and here those shadowy places are ambiguous in a different but still satisfying way. The climactic sequences of the book in its original form possessed a powerful and satisfying click as they fell into place and, under De Metter’s watch, the dread and revelation remain intact.

Shutter Island page

 
The story, set in 1954, presents a U.S. marshal and widower named Teddy Daniels who, with his new partner, is dispatched to an island with one dominant landmark: Ashecliffe Hospital, a fortress-like mental institution that is missing one of its mass murderers. A hurricane hits and the entire island becomes a wind-lashed prison where the simple case of an escapee deepens into a surreal puzzle. Daniels, who arrived on Shutter Island with his own inner demons, soon wonders what is real and who can be trusted.

Like Darwyn Cooke’s retro-crime masterpiece “The Hunter,” which was the best graphic novel of 2009, “Shutter Island” finds that less is more when it comes to the color palette; crime and punishment, it seems, are best presented in shades of iodine yellow and drowning-victim blue. There are only a few slashes of bright colors in the 128-page “Shutter” graphic novel and they are carefully placed to deepen the dream-time quality of Lehane’s carefully constructed nightmare.

Martin Scorsese, Leonardo DiCaprio and Paramount Pictures are bringing “Shutter Island” to the screen (finally) on Feb. 19 and a discerning consumer of culture might reasonably ask if it’s worth investing his or her time in a novel, a graphic novel and a film version of the same tale. The answer, so far, appears to be a resounding “yes.” One word of warning, however: The ending of “Shutter Island” is so jolting that any second-time encounter with the material (no matter the medium) will have a hard time matching the payoff of the first visit to the island. Choose your nightmares carefully.

– Geoff Boucher

RECENT AND RELATED

The Hunter by Darwyn Cooke

Darwyn Cooke and “The Hunter” pull off the perfect crime

“Filthy Rich” and the new surge in noir comics

Travis McGee may finally get his Hollywood close-up

REVIEW: “Ex Machina” is the perfectly wired graphic novel

The Hollywood history (and future) of Sherlock Holmes

David Fincher looks for the heart of “Torso”

Ed Brubaker meets his “Angel of Death”

REVIEW:“Best Crime Comics” is killer

“100 Bullets,” the final curtain falls on revenge saga 

Credit: “Shutter Island” artwork by Christian De Metter / Tokyopop/HarperCollins

Comments


6 Responses to ‘Shutter Island’ is a different nightmare in graphic novel form

  1. Ethan says:

    I just finished the novel and enjoyed reading it, but I unfortunately had the twist in the back of my head the whole time. (Possible spoiler…) When I saw the trailer for the film, which is why I read the novel, my first thoughts were immediately that I bet he's really a patient on the island. Why did I think this? I'm guessing because I've read One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Perhaps that combined with the way the trailer was made. Has anybody else read/seen Cuckoo's Nest that can relate? Obviously the ending is not the same but the premise is: that it's all made up.

  2. Andrew says:

    ARGH, ETHAN! Spoiler alert, please!
    If anyone's reading this page and is concerned about spoilers, PLEASE don't read Ethan's comment.
    I know it's one thing to say that certain endings of certain stories are telegraphed by their authors (perhaps most notoriously in The Sixth Sense?) but at least put a ***SPOILER*** warning on your post, as not everyone has read the book and the movie's only just coming out.

  3. Chico says:

    He does have (Possible spoiler…)
    Your best advice would be not to read any reviews. I learned that from Scorsese, who said he last review he read was in 1950 for Psycho. He opened up the Daily News and the first line was, "Anthony Perkins plays a psycho…" and said, "That's it!" Never read a review since.

  4. Sir William C. Ducut says:

    shutter island zombies more

  5. sirwilliam says:

    2100

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title="" rel=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <pre> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Close
E-mail It
Powered by ShareThis